Scottish judges reserve ruling on private prosecution bid over rape allegation
A panel chaired by Lord Pentland has reserved judgment on whether the complainant may bring a rare private prosecution against former Blackburn Rovers striker David Goodwillie.

A panel of three senior Scottish judges has reserved judgment on an application by a woman to bring a rare private prosecution against former Blackburn Rovers striker David Goodwillie over a rape allegation. The North West England link is through Goodwillie's time at Blackburn Rovers and his brief spell at Radcliffe; the application itself is being heard in Scotland, so the case touches the region through a footballer's career rather than a local criminal proceeding. The application, made through a Bill for Criminal Letters, comes after a 2017 civil court finding against Goodwillie and former Dundee United teammate David Robertson over the 2011 allegation; no criminal charges were brought against either man.
At Thursday's hearing, the Crown opposed the application. Advocate depute Alan Cameron said the Lord Advocate's position was that there were 'no exceptional circumstances which would permit the issuing of a Bill of Criminal Letters'. He added that a previous decision not to prosecute did not involve an 'egregious error' on the part of prosecutors. Lawyers for the complainant argued there was a reasonable prospect of conviction and urged the court to allow the case to proceed. Juliette Casey said: 'I urge the court, almost 16 years after the allegation of rape and almost 10 years after the civil case, to grant this Bill of Criminal Letters.'
Goodwillie's legal team argued the application should be refused. His counsel, Lord Stewart KC, highlighted concerns about potential prejudice arising from publicity generated by the earlier civil proceedings. The court was told evidence Goodwillie gave under oath during the civil case could potentially be admissible in any future private prosecution, although that would ultimately be a matter for any trial judge. Goodwillie has consistently denied wrongdoing and previously said he wanted to move on with his life.
After hearing submissions, Lord Pentland, Scotland's most senior judge, said: 'We will take some time to consider submissions,' adding that the court would issue a ruling 'as soon as practicable'. The application remains before the court after the panel reserved judgment. Goodwillie, 37, joined Blackburn Rovers from Dundee United in August 2011 in a deal reported to be worth around £2 million and made more than 28 appearances for the club. He played one league game for Radcliffe in February 2023, scoring a hat-trick, before being released following fan backlash relating to the 2017 civil court ruling; the club admitted a 'significant misstep' and said it 'sincerely apologised'.
Sources
2 original reports- Bury Times — CrimeGB12 November 2026
- Lancashire Telegraph — CrimeGB12 November 2026