Carlisle coach death: judge directs acquittal as careless driving sentence is awaited
Michael Cockton admitted careless driving after his coach struck Roger Denwood, 75, outside Carlisle railway station; a jury cleared him of the more serious charge on the judge's direction.

A judge at Carlisle Crown Court has directed the acquittal of a 49-year-old coach driver on a charge of causing death by dangerous driving, after the prosecution closed its case. Michael Cockton, of St Helens Avenue, Flimby, had already admitted causing death by careless driving, and is due to be sentenced for that offence on 11 December. The prosecution arose in Cumbria and turned on the standard of a professional driver's conduct at a station forecourt; the contested allegation ended in acquittal on judicial direction rather than by the jury's own verdict.
Facts heard in open court concern the evening of 30 November 2023, when Cockton was driving an empty rail replacement coach for the Silloth-based company Spencer Graham. Shortly before 6.20pm, in darkness, he entered the station car park through a "no entry" sign against the flow of other traffic, which the court heard was in accordance with an approved system that a barrister suggested "may defy logic". He was attempting to reverse into a parking space when, according to CCTV played in court, the coach nudged a parked car, stopped and then accelerated forward from 0 to 15 kilometres per hour (9.3mph) in three to four seconds over 10 metres, striking the station building. Roger Denwood, 75, from Cockermouth, who was standing close to the front entrance, was crushed and suffered serious injuries. Bystander Matthew Measor, one metre away, said: "I tried to grab the old guy from the coach coming towards us but was unable to grab him quick enough." Mr Denwood was treated at the scene and taken to Carlisle's Cumberland Infirmary, then transferred to Newcastle's Royal Victoria Infirmary, where he died on 15 December 2023.
Forensic collision investigator Gregg Beatson told the trial that the collision was caused by driver error: Cockton, he concluded, incorrectly believed the coach was in reverse gear when he pressed the accelerator, and would have had no time to react in the three to four seconds that followed. After the Crown closed its case, defence barrister Kim Whittlestone made a formal submission, with jurors absent, that there was insufficient evidence on which a jury could convict. Judge Nicholas Barker agreed, ruling: "This can only have been a momentary lapse of concentration in very difficult circumstances when all his other driving was careful and cautious." The jury of eight women and four men then unanimously acquitted Cockton on the judge's direction.
The case now moves to sentencing for the admitted offence of causing death by careless driving, listed for 11 December at the same court once a probation service pre-sentence report has been prepared. Cockton remains on bail until then. No jury finding was made on the dangerous driving allegation, which ended in acquittal on the judge's direction.
Sources
2 original reports- Times & Star — CrimeGB12 November 2026
- News & Star — CrimeGB12 November 2026