Skip to content
North West England crime, courts and policing, from local reporting← jrcriminaldefence.com
JR Criminal DefenceCrime News
Justice & LawStory of 6 November 2026

Self-defence finding ends assault case against Cheshire constable over custody struggle

PC Benjamin Betts, 24, was found not guilty of assault by beating after a judge said he could not be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the officer was not acting in self-defence.

Self-defence finding ends assault case against Cheshire constable over custody struggle
Symbolic illustration, generated for this briefing. It does not depict the people involved.

A Cheshire Police constable has been found not guilty of assault by beating over the force he used on an 80-year-old detainee at a custody suite in Runcorn, a case that turned on whether he was defending himself and a colleague. PC Benjamin Betts, 24, who has served with the force since 2020 on Warrington's response team, was cleared at Sefton Magistrates' Court. The verdict ends a criminal case that centred on the conduct of a night shift inside the custody suite, and it leaves the officer's disciplinary position to be settled by the police watchdog rather than by the courts.

Angela Conlan, leading the prosecution, told the court that the force used on Ronald Jarvis, which left him on the ground, was not necessary to calm the situation. Mr Jarvis, who was deaf and did not have his hearing aid, had been arrested on suspicion of drink driving and was being held at the suite. CCTV played in court showed him sitting on the floor of his cell at about 4.30am on 8 December calling for help; when Detention Officer Gaynor Tindall opened the door he stood and tried to get past her, saying "I can't stay here". Mr Betts told the court he was heading down the corridor of Block B towards another detainee he believed was having a medical emergency when he heard Ms Tindall shouting for help and saw her in what he described as a "bladed" stance. He said he placed himself between the two and held Mr Jarvis against the cell wall before pushing him to the ground to prevent harm and prevent escape.

Mr Betts maintained that his actions were in defence of himself and his colleague, saying Mr Jarvis was "actively assaulting her". Ms Tindall, who gave evidence as a witness, described Mr Jarvis as "really strong" and said the interaction made her "really frightened"; Mr Betts, she said, "came in and got him off me, then created a space so we could shut the door". Judge Hatton said it was for the Crown Prosecution Service to disprove beyond all reasonable doubt that Mr Betts had acted in defence of himself or someone else, and that he took the view it would be "entirely impossible" for the CPS to prove that self-defence was not an issue. "I cannot be satisfied beyond all reasonable doubt," the judge said.

The Independent Office for Police Conduct, which brought the case to the CPS, will now decide whether further disciplinary processes take place. David Pearson, a specialist civil liberties lawyer at Broudie Jackson Canter who represents the family, said: "While my clients are disappointed by the verdict, they respect the decision of the court." Mr Jarvis later became seriously unwell while in custody, reportedly suffering a seizure and a stroke, and was taken to Warrington Hospital, according to the Liverpool Echo. The next step is the IOPC's decision on disciplinary proceedings, on which no outcome has been indicated.

cheshire policecustody suiteiopcpolice assault acquittal

Sources

4 original reports
  1. Northwich Guardian — CrimeGB6 November 2026
  2. Runcorn & Widnes World — CrimeGB6 November 2026
  3. Warrington Guardian — CrimeGB6 November 2026
  4. Liverpool Echo — CourtsGB6 November 2026