Skip to content
North West England crime, courts and policing, from local reporting← jrcriminaldefence.com
JR Criminal DefenceCrime News
Justice & LawStory of 28 October 2026

Three sentenced over false reports that ended St Helens stabbing inquiry

Walid Gbeira, Nicole McMenamy and Caitlyn Waring admitted conspiracy to pervert the course of justice after police concluded witness-intimidation reports had been fabricated.

Three sentenced over false reports that ended St Helens stabbing inquiry
Symbolic illustration, generated for this briefing. It does not depict the people involved.

Three people have been sentenced at Liverpool Crown Court over a conspiracy to pervert the course of justice that led a stabbing investigation in St Helens to be abandoned. Walid Gbeira, 39, of no fixed abode, was sentenced to three years in prison on 23 October; Nicole McMenamy, 27, of Baltimore Drive, St Helens, received two years and five months; and Caitlyn Waring, 26, of Linear View, Newton-le-Willows, was given 15 months in prison suspended for two years. The case belongs to the criminal justice system in Merseyside, where the collapse of the original assault inquiry turned on the reliability of the accounts police had been given.

The proceedings trace back to 23 November 2021, when a man in his 30s reported being attacked by four men at a property on Sunners Green Close in Parr. As the investigation progressed, Gbeira, the man who had reported the stabbing, and people connected to him reported multiple incidents of witness intimidation and threatening phone calls. A man was charged with witness intimidation and remanded in custody, spending 63 days in prison, before the case was discontinued after telecommunications analysis revealed significant inconsistencies and indicated the allegations were false. Officers then suspected a deliberate attempt to influence the investigation, prompting a separate inquiry into conspiracy to pervert the course of justice.

Search warrants were executed in August 2022 at the homes of Gbeira and McMenamy, whose home was where the stabbing was reported to have taken place. Examinations of mobile devices recovered in the searches found call records, messages, videos and covert recordings which, the sources state, showed a co-ordinated effort to mislead police, fabricate allegations and falsely implicate others. Gbeira pleaded guilty on the first day of his trial in June; McMenamy and Waring both pleaded guilty before trial. Detective Chief Inspector Lisa McNaughton said: "It is only thanks to the hard work and determination of the investigation team that we were able to unpick their lies and successfully convict them and put them behind bars."

No further action was taken in relation to the stabbing. The prosecution concluded there was no longer a realistic prospect of conviction because of concerns about the reliability and credibility of Gbeira and McMenamy, both key witnesses, and those concerns arose from evidence uncovered during the perverting the course of justice investigation. The sentences handed down on 23 October close the conspiracy proceedings; the account of the 2021 assault itself has not been tested in court.

perverting the course of justicesentencingstabbingst helens

Sources

2 original reports
  1. Liverpool Echo — CourtsGB28 October 2026
  2. St Helens Star — CrimeGB28 October 2026