Skip to content
North West England crime, courts and policing, from local reporting← jrcriminaldefence.com
JR Criminal DefenceCrime News
Justice & LawStory of 15 November 2026

Appeal court refuses sentence challenges by two men convicted over Glasgow murder plot

Judges uphold 13- and 11-year terms given to David Nisbet and Declan McCuish, rejecting arguments that the sentences for conspiring to kill a Glasgow target were excessive.

Appeal court refuses sentence challenges by two men convicted over Glasgow murder plot
Symbolic illustration, generated for this briefing. It does not depict the people involved.

Appeal judges in Scotland have refused attempts by two convicted men to reduce the prison terms imposed for a conspiracy to murder that was arranged with a would-be Liverpool hitman and abandoned at the final stage. The written judgement closes the sentencing stage of a case whose investigation ran through Merseyside: the intended gunman, James Richards, was collected from Liverpool, the conspiracy was found to have been carried out at addresses in Glasgow, East Dunbartonshire and Liverpool, and encrypted messages were subsequently analysed after European law enforcement hacked the EncroChat network.

David Nisbet, 36, and Declan McCuish were jailed last year for 13 years and 11 years respectively over the 2020 plot. Both denied conspiring to murder and were found guilty. At an appeal hearing last month, Nisbet, who did not have a lawyer, told Lord Beckett, Lord Matthews and Lord Ericht that sentences given to people convicted of similar offences were not as long as his, and asked the court to reduce his term "in the interests of justice". McCuish's lawyer told the judges the sentence was too harsh because he did not play as large a role as other participants, and that the trial judge should have imposed a lesser term.

In a written judgement, Lord Beckett wrote: "We are not persuaded that it was an excessive sentence, there was no miscarriage of justice." Both appeals were refused. Prosecutor Lindsey Dalziel said Nisbet "called the shots" and that the group "sought to turn the streets of Glasgow into a warzone" in an effort to catch the target. EncroChat messages from April 2020 showed Nisbet suggesting three potential hitmen before an agreement was reached with Richards for a £70,000 payment, and McCuish was in charge of securing a hideout for him.

Richards was given a gun on 11 April of that year and taken on a tour of places where the target was likely to be that day, but pulled out after raising concerns about the car he would use to leave the scene and asking for a faster car or a motorbike. He returned to Liverpool on 13 April, when police stopped his car on the M74; nothing of note was found, but subsequent analysis of EncroChat revealed the scope of his involvement. Richards was arrested in June 2021 and released under investigation, then fled to Spain and remained there until he was extradited in January 2026; he was sentenced to seven years and six months. Anthony Connell, who messaged his accomplices about a "Scouser wanting to blow him away", was sentenced to six years nine months. The appeal ruling leaves the terms imposed on Nisbet and McCuish unchanged; whether any further legal challenge is planned was not stated.

appeal courtconspiracy to murdergangsterssentencing

Sources

2 original reports
  1. Manchester Evening News — CrimeGB15 November 2026
  2. Liverpool Echo — CourtsGB15 November 2026